If you have a narrow heel, we recommend going down a half size. We recommend going up a half size if you run wide.
Mr. York is made on our Austin last, one of our favorite lasts with an almond-shaped toe. Shaped with a woman's foot in mind, this silhouette has great feminine appeal. If you’re on the narrow side and tend to slip out of shoes, these will be a great choice.
Beautiful shoe bad fit
The shoe is well made and is beautiful. I chose Mahogany. I ordered a 1/2 size up, however when it arrived, it was too wide at the heel. It would slide off. So i returned and ordered my actual size of 8.5. The shoe fits with no room to spare. I still had to add the heel stickers because my foot still slides out. I cannot wear socks because even with he heel sticker my foot slides out of the shoe. at least w/no socks i have more grip. I use them because i want my $$$ worth. However, the fit of this shoe is a problem. I also own a pair of Mr. Franklins. I ordered my exact size of 8.5 and they fit perfectly and never slide off. However i probably won't order another pair of Monkstraps due to fit.
Rated 3 out of 5
Rated -1 on a scale of minus 2 to 2, where minus 2 is Runs Small, 0 is True to Size and 2 is Runs Large
The Office of Angela Scott
I'm sorry this style isn't working out for you. This particular color in Mr. York has a wider ankle cut that can cause heel slip with the lug sole. It is something we have been working on and believe the newer colors in Mr. York (black and white) have solved this issue to provide a better fit. I will reach out directly to help further with your order.
Please always reach out via email or phone if you have any questions or concerns with your order so we can help immediately. We want you to have a pair of shoes you will love!